Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If you are self-employed in Germany (i.e. most high earners that earn over 200k) then you pay around 1100-1200EUR/month on health insurance which is more than a family health insurance plan in the US. Moreover, even if you earn only 62000EUR, you pay 1100+EUR/month, which is absolutely ridiculous given other taxes and VAT.


> most high earners that earn over 200k

Those incomes are by definition restricted to the top 5% of the general population - of course those top earners prefer not to be enrolled in a socialized medicine plan and prefer market insurance with a nominal price tag that is not proportional to income.

That's the entire point, to establish a social contract where the healthy and successful pay for the healthcare of the less fortunate, can benefit themselves from that social net if their fortune reverse, and deal with the risk they might never be net beneficiaries if they remain healthy and wealthy.

Given the option, high earners would argue that all public spending should be financed by flat nominal taxes, it's not like they personally require more work from the army or the police, or they drive longer distances on public infrastructure.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: